Time to Rethink Where To Use Whole-House Fans
I have to say that my experience with whole-house fans has not always been positive. I remember almost 20 years ago, my husband and I went to dinner at a friend's house near Detroit. The living room was getting warm even though it was cool outside, so our friend said he was going to turn on the whole-house fan instead of the air conditioner. No sooner did he flip the switch than it sounded like a helicopter had landed on the roof. Papers blew everywhere, and our previously calm, quiet conversation turned into a shouting match, just so we could hear each other above the din.
At that point, I would have been horrified if an HVAC contractor suggested putting one of those beasts in our house. But times have changed, and now I'd love it if someone offered to install one of the new, smarter, and thankfully, quieter, whole-house fans in our home. The problem is that many HVAC contractors just don't offer these types of products to their customers.
A whole-house fan is a fairly simple device. The fan is mounted in the ceiling of a central hallway (in the top floor of a two-story house) and draws cool outside air in through open doors and windows while forcing the hottest indoor air out the existing intake and exhaust vents on the roof. This cycle creates a comfortable living environment and reduces the air conditioning load for the next day.
A whole-house fan is effective whenever the outside temperature is lower than the indoor temperature, which is usually in the evenings and at night. It typically uses just one-tenth the energy of air conditioning, which means drastically lower energy bills for the typical residence.
In dry desert climates, a whole-house fan is a no-brainer, according to Neil Smith, P.E., president, HVACQuick.com, San Jose, Calif., as it can minimize or nearly eliminate the need for air conditioning completely. "What many people don't realize however, is that even in most other areas of the United States, you can use it in conjunction with your a/c to dramatically reduce your energy consumption."
Paul H. Raymer, president, Tamarack Technologies Inc., Buzzards Bay, Mass., agreed, noting that "Several years ago a study was done on whole-house fans in Florida, and the conclusion was that, while they can increase humidity, fans reduce the temperature in a home. The study involved 384 single-family homes, apartments, and condos, and it showed that by using natural ventilation instead of air conditioning, 777 kWh was saved. So if you can use a fan, it does reduce the air conditioning costs wherever you are."
Obviously, the warmer and more humid the evening air, the less effective natural cooling becomes; however, whole-house fans are often used successfully to complement air conditioning systems. Most fan manufacturers state that as long as the outside temperature is below 75Â°F, a whole-house fan can effectively cool a home.
NEW DESIGNS, EASIER INSTALLATION
The traditional whole-house fan is fairly large and noisier than small fans, but can move between 4,000 and 7,000 cfm of air. This type of fan is installed in the ceiling, and louvers open when the fan is turned on. Newer whole-house fans are available that have a flow range between 1,000 and 3,000 cfm.
"The real distinction between the two," noted Raymer, "is if people want to feel a breeze moving through the house, then they need to get the bigger fans. If they want to cool the house down slowly over a longer period of time, then the smaller fans work great. They're quieter and more energy efficient, but they won't create the kind of breeze that a 7,000-cfm fan will."
Besides being significantly quieter, the new fans have motorized, insulated, sealed damper doors; no framing is required during installation; and a smaller fan running all night long will use much less energy compared to air conditioning. In addition, the house will be cooler in the morning.
The one major requirement for a whole-house fan is that the home has to have an attic with a certain amount of clearance, noted Paul Scelsi, training and communications manager, Air Vent, Dallas. "The installation instructions of the various models and brands make that clear."
In addition, a home must have a sufficient amount of attic ventilation in order to exhaust the air. If there is not enough ventilating, the resulting positive pressure will force hot, dusty attic air back into the house through light fixtures and other cracks. Smith noted that 1 square foot of unobstructed venting should be allowed for every 450 cfm, and double that amount of venting is required if the vent is obstructed by insect screening, louvers, etc. Basically, a 1,700-cfm fan requires approximately 4 square feet of unobstructed roof venting.
As for the correct fan size for a house, most manufacturers provide worksheets to determine this information, but a typical rule of thumb for the newer whole-house fans is 1,000 cfm for a 1,500-square-foot house.
So if a whole-house fan saves energy, improves IAQ, offers a quick payback to customers, and increases a homeowner's comfort level, why aren't more HVAC contractors offering these products to customers? It's difficult to say. Perhaps it's an issue of education - both the contractor's and the homeowner's - or maybe it's price, as the newer whole-house fans are substantially more expensive than the traditional models. What is known is that the other trades are making money installing whole-house fans in residential applications.
"Right now, it's the electricians who are usually putting in the whole-house fans," said Raymer. "It would be a very profitable service for heating and cooling contractors to offer, because they're already in a house and the fans can help make any air conditioning system work better."
And all contractors know that any type of differentiation from the competition is a good thing.
Sidebar: Attic Fans?
There's a big difference between a whole-house fan and an attic fan. Attic fans are designed to ventilate the attic space only, while whole-house fans are designed to ventilate the living space within a home. Whole-house fans generally operate during the summer, while attic fans can be used year-round.
The Home Ventilating Institute (www.hvi.org) refers to whole-house fans as whole-house comfort ventilators, and they are designed to bring in cooler outside air, draw it through the house, and push the house air out through the attic vents. Attic fans are used to reduce heat buildup in an attic and are helpful in preventing the deterioration of a home's structural components due to excess heat and humidity.
It is possible - and perhaps even beneficial - to install both an attic fan and a whole-house fan, depending on the climate. If both were installed, noted Paul Scelsi, Air Vent, Dallas, the whole-house fan would pull the outdoor air from open windows inside the living space, then dump the air into the attic space. From there, the attic fan would quickly exhaust the heat-and-moisture-laden air to the outdoors, as long as the conditions necessary to activate the attic fan's controllers were met.
"Most parts of the country can benefit from attic fans because they help to fight heat buildup inside the attic in the summer and moisture buildup in the winter," said Scelsi. "Whole-house fans work best in climates that experience moderate, less humid summers."
Publication date: 07/24/2006
The finished walk-out basement is fairly cool, but if I open a window to allow the
AC? Lots of people are buying air conditioners for this heat wave. And once installed, one tends to use AC, and it is a significant contributor to Climate Crisis. I love open windows, breezes, and my house is usually fine in summer, but things are changing rather fast. I am aware that AC exists, it's not a good answer to this particular ask.
The finished walk-out basement is fairly cool, but if I open a window to allow the stack effect, it lets in a lot of ground-level moisture and seems counter-productive. I do close windows downstairs, open 1 door, and can feel the air moving if I stand on the stairs. Pleasant, but not enough. There's no attic, and no access to whatever tiny crawl-space may exist. If I add a fan to exhaust hot air, what size? How do I assess the air-moving capability? Wattage? I don't think the classic 20 buck box fans are all that strong; I have several and use them for personal cooling. I do close sunny windows and drapes in the morning, it doesn't seem to do much. There's a 1st-floor deck and patio umbrellas to reduce sun.AC? Lots of people are buying air conditioners for this heat wave. And once installed, one tends to use AC, and it is a significant contributor to Climate Crisis. I love open windows, breezes, and my house is usually fine in summer, but things are changing rather fast. I am aware that AC exists, it's not a good answer to this particular ask.